Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (12): Parenting Boys and Girls

Boy with flowersGender is no doubt a huge factor in parenting. Many parents would like to know their baby's gender before it is born, because gender matters to them. In our society, the role of girls and women is different from the role of boys and men. It is hard to ignore these roles and treat kids equally, because in the eyes of our society they are not equal.

So what should we do? Should we parent our kids differently if they are boys or girls or should we treat them just the same?

Research on people's attitude towards boys and girls has found that parents and adults generally treat boys and girls differently even when they are just babies. In a famous research done with a group of babies that were dressed in pink or blue (without any relation to their real gender) the researchers discovered that the pink babies (presumably the girls) were picked up more by the adults and received more eye contact than the blue babies (presumably the boys).

How do you think this translates to parenting?

Well, I decided to ask the Top Parenting Bloggers about their attitude towards parenting boys vs. girls. As usual, it was very interesting to read their comments.

What, if any, are the differences between parenting boys and girls?

Richard JaramillioRichard "RJ" Jaramillo - Single Dad

Fathers shape daughters and mothers shape sons. These relationships carry a lot of responsibility and every parent should know how much they will make a difference on how their children will be in the future.

Sue Scheff

Sue Scheff - Sue Scheff Blog

This is an interesting question since you can quiz a variety of parents and each will have a different answer.

For me, my daughter was easier as a child through elementary, while my son was very difficult to keep entertained, but as teenage years came around, my daughter was a handful and my son was fantastic. I think the differences are personal and vary within each unique family.

Susan HeimSusan Heim - Susan Heim on Parenting

As a mother of four boys, I can tell you that it's constant chaos. While girls are quietly coloring at a table, boys are running around the room and trying to tackle one another. Of course, there are calm boys and active girls, but for the most part, they're very different.

Boys and girls learn, play, and act differently, and it's important for educators and parents to recognize these differences and adapt to them. Often, boys are labeled naughty when they're just doing what boys are genetically programmed to do!

Annie Fox

Annie Fox, M.Ed. - From the desk of Annie Fox

The differences in our parenting approaches to each of them come from their individual personality and temperamental differences. They are not a function of gender.

Maria Melo - Conversations with Moms

Conversations with Moms

I have two boys and 6 nephews. I know that when the cousins get together, it's a madhouse. They love action and at times seem fearless. They are very adventurous and their energy seems to have no end.

There are many studies that detail the physiological, emotional, analytical and behavioral differences between boys and girls, so I won't repeat what I'm sure you've already heard or read.

I can tell you that as a mother of two boys, I know that one of the lessons I hope to teach them is to respect women. Hopefully, I can teach them to respect their minds and hearts as well as admire their beauty.

If I had a daughter, I would try to teach her to respect herself and not fall victim to what society says she should look like.

Annie - PhD in Parenting

PhD in Parenting

I addressed this topic recently on my blog. In summary, in a perfect world, I do not think we would need to parent boys and girls differently. However, due to the messages that society sends our girls and our boys about their gender and the opposite gender, I do think that we need to parent them differently, because we need to counteract those messages.

Ultimately I think it is important for us to parent each of our children as individuals and not as a member of a specific gender group. This is true both because gender stereotyping is harmful and also because we cannot be 100% certain that we know the gender of our child until they tell us (as their gender assigned at birth may not be their true gender).

Read more in my post called "Should we parent boys and girls differently?"

Ria SharonRia Sharon - My Mommy Manual

This begs generalizations and I don't know that my observations are universal. In my house, although both my kids are physical in the sense of wanting to be held and touched, my son's need to run and wrestle and play physically is higher than my daughter's.

So with parenting, using visual cues and physical contact are much more effective - putting a hand on his shoulder, hugging as we take deep breaths, etc.

Ronit Baras - Family Matters

Ronit BarasI do not think there needs to be a major difference between parenting boys and girls (I think parenting the eldest and the youngest is much more different). If anything, this stereotypical misconception of gender is a social pattern I need to fight. I do not go for pink for girls, blue for boys, dolls for girls, cars for boys, cooking and make up toys for girls, science and outdoor toys for boys.

As much as I would like to say that I parent my kids the same, I don't. I have put are stickers on our dining room board and on some of my boxes that say "Girls can do anything", yet I do not have any that say "Boys can do anything", although I think they can too.

When my son decided to register himself to dancing, I encouraged him more and paid more attention to him than I did with my two other girls' dancing. Why? Because he was the only boy in his dance class, while my girls were part of the majority of girls in their classes.

So no, I do not treat my kids the same, but I expect the same from them. I expect all three of them to go after their dreams, even if it means they are the only boy in their cooking class or the only girl wearing blue. However, I need to support them differently, depending on which social norm I am helping them fight.

I do not believe boys and girls are different in their abilities, but they must face different perceptions by the media, peers, fashion and the adults in their life. As their parents, we face the same challenges with them.

There is no "All boys are.." and no "All girls are…" and I tell my daughters exactly the same massage I tell my son - that they are unique and wonderful and if they focus on what they can do, achieve, feel and have with the gender they have, they will enjoy life greatly.

Many thanks to the Top Parenting Bloggers: RJ, Annie Fox, Ria, Annie, Maria, Susan and Sue for sharing their thoughts about gender and parenting boys and girls.

I know this is a very hot topic and the debate about what is our role in creating equal opportunities for our boys and girls is very old but still important, so please join the discussion by writing your thoughts about parenting boys and girls.

Join us next week's Top Parenting Bloggers discussion about parenting teens. Parenting teens and educating teens is a topic that is very close to my heart. I hope many parents for teens and people working with teens will join us and write their ideas too.

We are approaching the end of the Top Parenting Bloggers Discussion, so I wanted to encourage you to add questions to the discussion that you would like answered. You can post them in the comment box below as suggestions for discussion.

If you wish to know more about the bloggers who take part in this project or contact any of them, please visit their blogs, follow them on Twitter and/or become their fan on Facebook. Alternatively, you can send them a question or comment through the comment box below.

Happy parenting,
Ronit

Related posts

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

21 Responses to “Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (12): Parenting Boys and Girls”

  • RT @ronitbaras: Parenting Boys & Girls http://ow.ly/1X131 @Annie_Fox @SueScheff @ParentingAuthor @rjsingledad @phdinparenting @Convers ...

  • Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • [...] more about parenting boys and girls… Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)12 Year Old Boy Has Sex ChangeWhy Gender [...]

  • RT @ronitbaras: Parenting Boys & Girls http://ow.ly/1X131 @Annie_Fox @SueScheff @ParentingAuthor @rjsingledad @phdinparenting @Convers ...

  • RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • RT @ronitbaras Parenting Boys & Girls http://ow.ly/1X131 @Annie_Fox @SueScheff @ParentingAuthor #parenting

  • Understanding Gender Differences: Strategies to Support Girls and Boys
    Ways the current research on gender development can be applied in our homes, schools and communities to support young people in growing up whole-that is, beyond the cultural limitations of gender roles
    http://www.umext.maine.edu/onlinepubs/PDFpubs/4423.pdf

    Just boys, just girls and just schooling: Curriculum, behaviours (including bullying) and gender
    A professional development paper focusing on gender perspectives across the curriculum
    http://www.sacsa.sa.edu.au/ATT/%7BB116A2B7-F89E-4898-B172-7A10231963D7%7D/boysgirls.pdf

  • RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Parenting Boys and Girls - Does gender make a difference? http://tinyurl.com/28mbf82

  • As a women working in a prodominantly male dominated profession, engineering, and a very young mother of my first son 33 years ago I was an idealist and determined to not assign gender roles or toys. I bought him dolls as well as cars but didn't allow guns in the house. Eventually he threw the dolls out the window stuck some leggo pieces together and made his own gun and ran around the house pointing at everything shouting "pchew pchew". I threw up my hands in defeat. After all that, my elder son chose a caree in the arts. My second son was the complete opposite in temperament and nature and although he chose a career as a macho tradesman is the gentler natured and more caring of the two. One thing I've learned from raising two very different sons is all generalisations are wrong.

  • RT @ronitbaras Parenting Boys & Girls
    http://ow.ly/1X131

    RT @MommyNews: Motherhood: The days are long, bu... http://tinyurl.com/38pqoex

  • I've never raised a girl, but all my friends without boys wonder how on earth I do it. I don't know any differently. But while generalizations may not always be right, I think boys and girls are very different. I have to take my husband's word on a lot of things that I just don't get at all. Sometimes I'm wanting to be all soft and mommy-like, and he says, "Those boys need a lesson!!"

  • The research didn't say what gender where the adults or lets assume an equal number of male and female? I would say female would tend to choose pink color while men would opt for blue. I know I would pick up blue over pink. I think it's because pink would be stereotyped as a girly color.

  • I've raised two boys and one girl. I can tell you that they are programmed very differently. My daughter Zoe is the middle child. I'm not very feminine myself so treated her exactly the same as her younger brother since birth, dressing her in pink, blue, yellow. At 18 months she astounded me. I had given her the usual large buttons, spools and giant needle for threading. Zoe put the spool on the button as a cup and saucer and used the needle as a spoon. I was shocked as we only use mugs in our house.

  • HI Maria,

    Thank you so much for the link.
    I hope many parents will visit it and learn more about gender.
    I think we neglect to pay enough attention to the gender issue as our kids are young and later on we face many difficulties related to it.

    Thanks and hugs
    Ronit
    Parenting Classes

  • Hi Susan,

    What an awesome example of raising two sons that are totally different.
    I am sure that allowing them to play with dolls gave them a permission to choose. Still, there is society around and very fast after going to a day care or school they "learn" what society thinks about what boys and what girls should do. Some of them are strong enough ( strong means have strong parents) to choose what suits them and what doesn't. Others just pick a role that is expected of them and take the risk of living an unfulfilled life.
    When my son Tsoof was young, we kept guns from him for about 3 years. One day, a gift arrived by post to his third birthday. My sister sent him some toys to play with and as I opened it there was an Uzi gun in it, you know, the one that makes noises when you shoot. Gal and I looked at each other in terror. I was so upset with my sister. The second he saw it, he picked it up in excitement and pressed it. Every time I heard the sound of the shooting, I felt my heart was broken. I wanted to prevent him from this a bit longer. I knew I couldn't do it forever but hoped that at least for another year or two and then he took the gun and went to the wall, pressed it against the wall and was very excited with then noise it made. Then, he moved to another wall and pressed it against the wall again. Gal and I looked at each other shocked. He was so happy and excited and for about 15 minutes he moved from one wall to another and pressed it and then he said:
    "Now I have a drill, just like dad's"

    I love drills. They are very useful in the house.

    Thanks Susan
    Happy weekend
    Ronit
    Parenting Classes

  • HI Angela,

    I am sure raising boys only is not the same as raising a mix from both genders.
    I grew up in a family with 4 girls one boy and in my house there are two girls and one boy and the boy is the "Sandwich" kid. ( We gave the sandwich concept a different meaning).
    kids are kids, and boys are also kids. some of them are rough, some of them are soft, some of them are creative, some of them are academic, some of them are more friendly than others and some prefers just a small group of friends.
    I think if we treat them as individuals instead of putting them in a category of " all boys need..." we will give them the freedom to BE, instead of the pressure to fit.

    Happy parenting
    Ronit
    Parenting Classes

  • Hi Jill,

    I agree with you that boys and girls are programed differently but I think they are programed by our society to be different and I think that in some areas it is working well and others are not.

    Whenever individuality is pushed to the side by generalisations it prevents children ( and grownups ) from being natural and following their own intuition and natural tendencies.
    We have a problem in our society that if boys wants to do cooking or sing, they need to overcome their parents' stereotypical ideas about what is suitable for boys and girls.
    When teenagers choose coursed or a path in high school that will lead them to a profession, they are highly influenced by what the society thinks is suitable. How many girl mechanics do you know? Why? do you really think that girls just don't have it? Did you know that in science and math subjects there are more boys than girls and that most sports teachers are male? So, no, we don't have to say things to program them to think that those things are feminine or masculine - we can go with them once to a toy shop for them to get the best social lesson of in life.
    girls toys are pink, purple and all about caring for others, cleaning the house, babies and beauty. ( and only when they are teens and obsessed with the way they look we ask, "What have we done wrong?")
    Boys toys are brown and black and are all about sport, monsters, cars,science and scary and aggressive acts ( ah, and if they do something in the house it is the outdoor of the house - fixing and garden)
    I agree with you Jill, they are programed but without awareness we will sit on the stand in the parenting trial and lose.

    Happy Parenting

    Ronit
    Parenting Classes

  • Hi Brian,

    I think this is the problem, associating pink with girls and blue with boys - which limits the boys and the girls.

Please share your throughts

Your comment will be moderated by its RELEVANCE and its VALUE to our readers.

Comments links could be nofollow free.

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Ronit Baras

Be Happy in LIFE logo     Find out today
how to be happy in life
with the help of a life coach
Blog by Ronit Baras
Ronit Baras
Suscribe by RSS
RSS icon
Subscribe by Email
How happy are you?
Follow me on
Twitter logo
Be my friend on
Facebook

What would you like to read about most (choose as many as you like)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Help us help you
Spacer image