Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (8): Discipline

DisciplineFor some reason, parenting and discipline go together. After all, in order for us to run a home properly, we must set some rules and make sure we follow them to everyone's benefit, right?

Setting rules and following a discipline routine is not easy. It requires parents to have lots of discipline and self control. To my surprise, when people seek parenting programs to enhance their parenting skills, they look for disciplining tricks and techniques when in fact, what they need is not a one-size-fits-all way of parenting but exposure to many different philosophies, which they can adapt to their own kids, beliefs and circumstances.

Parental discipline can be one or a mixture of the following definitions:

  1. A set or system of rules and regulations
  2. Training to act in accordance with rules like military discipline
  3. Activity, exercise or a routine that develops or improves a skill. For example a daily practice of the musician is an excellent discipline
  4. Punishment given to correct the behavior or skill
  5. Behavior that matches the rules of behavior for example: My son has good discipline as he goes to sleep early every night to allow himself to get up early in the morning for his rehearsal

If you examine your life, you will be able to find that you fit into one of these categories. Parents who focus on the skills and the behavior have a different discipline style to parents who focus on the rules.

As I prepared for this Top Parenting Bloggers project, I thought that the topic of discipline was probably something every parent would like to hear from people who have made parenting a high priority and somehow managed it well. Here are their answers.

What is your discipline philosophy?

Annie Fox, M.Ed. - From the desk of Annie Fox

Annie FoxDiscipline should never include verbal or physical abuse. Nor should parents ever threaten or intentionally frighten a child. That said, figure out your parenting objectives - that is, what skills and personal qualities you'd like your child to have by the time he/she is 18. Know how you intend to teach to those objectives. Make your expectations for their behavior crystal clear.

The consequences for missing the mark on those expectations must be equally clear in the mind of the child. When the child chooses to break the rules then the pre-determined consequence immediately comes into play. By being clear and consistent with expectations, praise for compliance and discipline for non-compliance, there is much less confusion in the mind of the child and a much greater likelihood for consistent cooperative behavior.

One more important point: if you are raising children with a partner, make sure the two of you are on the same page! If not, get there!

Conversations with MomsMaria Melo - Conversations with Moms

Be consistent about my discipline

Follow through with consequences

Ensure that the consequence matches the inappropriate behavior

Always make it about the behavior and never the person

Annie - PhD in Parenting

PhD in ParentingI believe in gentle discipline, focused around modeling appropriate behavior, giving them choices and teaching them about the things I think are important and that I think will help them in life. I do not believe in spanking or any other form of corporal punishment. But there are other tools, like rewards and punishments, which I will use as a last resort. I wrote more about my discipline spectrum on my blog: http://www.phdinparenting.com/2008/10/20/my-discipline-spectrum/.

Ria Sharon - My Mommy Manual

Ria SharonYogi Parenting. I've been a student of Michaela Turner's yoga-inspired approach to parenting for the last two years. This approach takes the principles of yoga: centering, boundaries, ritual and peace and applies them to parenting. I have learned how to teach my kids to discipline themselves, instead of trying to control them. It has truly transformed my relationship with my kids and my experience as a mom, which is why I am helping to develop an eCourse to be able to share this approach with other parents.

Richard "RJ" Jaramillo - Single Dad

Richard JaramillioBe the "Pack Leader" of your family and set a good example and you never have to worry about exercising discipline in your family (watch the TV show "Dog Whisperer" about Cesar Milan).

Sue Scheff - Sue Scheff Blog

Sue Scheff

I don't believe in corporal punishment and I am completely against boot camps. I do believe that discipline needs to be consistent. Time out is a common form of discipline, which I believe can be effective, as long as the parent follows through. As your child gets older, removing privileges is a form of punishment I used. However, again, you need to be consistent and always follow through. Making threats you don't follow through with sends your teen the message that you are all talk and they don't have to worry about their phone being taken from them.

Susan Heim - Susan Heim on Parenting

Susan Heim

Every child is different. What works for one child may not work for another. The child's gender, temperament, maturity and other factors must be considered when assigning consequences. And if you say there will be a consequence for something (i.e., no video games if you don't finish your homework), you must follow through, no matter how difficult it is.

Ronit Baras - Family Matters

Ronit BarasI do not like the word discipline at all. I see myself more as a captain running a ship, with all the responsibility that comes with it. So for me, a parent is more of a leader than a boss telling everyone what to do.

I am a life coach and believe with all my heart in supporting my kids' emotional development. I do not believe in punishment but in encouraging good behavior, because in life, you get what you focus on. It is an old teachers' trick - ignore undesired behavior, but highlight, encourage and congratulate desired behavior - and it works brilliantly. Instead of saying, "You are rude to your sister", I find one good example and say "You are such a wonderful brother helping your sister with her lunch box" and, just like magic, it becomes the norm. If it does not happen the way I prefer it, I think it is always because I have not highlighted the good behavior enough.

If I do things my kids do not like, I explain once, twice, three times. Sometimes they cannot understand, just because they are just kids. If I have not convinced them, I tell them that that's what captains do, they are there to make the decisions and parents are the captains of their household, so they will have to accept my decision.

I believe that having rules and boundaries is very important for kids. They are there to give kids stability, confidence and a sense of safety, not to limit them. Consistent parenting provides this safe zone to the kids. If there is a breach of rule, it is always because I wasn't clear about the rule in the first place.

So now that you know how the Top Parenting Bloggers think, what is your parenting philosophy? Use the comment box below to share with us your thoughts and comments.

Join us again next week, when the top parenting bloggers discuss their profound parenting moments.

If you wish to know more about the bloggers who take part in this project or contact any of them, please visit their blogs, follow them on Twitter and/or become their fan on Facebook. Alternatively, you can send them a question or comment through the comment box below.

Thanks again to Susan, Sue, Annie and Annie Fox, RJ, Ria and.

Happy parenting,
Ronit

Related posts

Related posts brought to you by Yet Another Related Posts Plugin.

9 Responses to “Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (8): Discipline”

  • Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (8): Discipline http://bit.ly/dbaucD

  • Ronit Baras:

    Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss (8): Discipline http://ow.ly/1KVVx #parenting #discipline #behavior

  • Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Discipline - http://tinyurl.com/38vunls @ronitbaras

  • Interesting discussion. RT @ParentingAuthor: Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss Discipline - http://tinyurl.com/38vunls @ronitbaras

  • RT @ronitbaras: Top #Parenting Bloggers Discuss (8): #Discipline http://bit.ly/c7k8eR

  • Jon:

    I agree with most all of them that said they do not believe in corporeal punishment, and I especially enjoyed Ronit's comparison of the home to a ship with the parent as the captain. Thanks for this article.

  • Thanks for bringing together all of these thoughtful ideas about healthy discipline.
    Let’s not forget the foundation of healthy discipline, a valuing relationship. Here are several tips I’ve routinely discussed with parents throughout my nearly forty years as a child psychotherapist, counseling more than 2,500 kids. (And it’s worked with my four grown kids and nine “grand” kids, as well.)
    Bonding activities (fosters “My mom and dad care”):

    • Family time: one family night a week
    • One-to-one time: 15 minutes, two times a week on school nights, doing what the kid wants to do; and 2 to 3 hours once a month (weekends), away from home

    Communication guidelines (fosters “I’m acceptable,” “I’m understood”):

    • Validate a kid’s feelings during problem-solving: “I can see you were really upset; tell me more.” Then deal with the problem.
    • Ask, “What do you think?” whenever possible (TV show, current events), and try to agree with something the child says. Support appropriate differences.
    • Modify your decision: “I can see where you’re coming from. You can clean your room on Saturday afternoon instead of Friday night.” Do this at least 20 percent of the time during your problem-solving.
    • Use the 75/25 rules. Rule 1: listen 75 percent of the time; talk 25 percent. Rule 2: use positive interaction 75 percent of the time; offer constructive feedback no more than 25 percent of the time.

    A valuing relationship guarantees more success with discipline.

  • Hi Gary,

    I love your suggestions. Thanks!
    I guess hearing it ( well, reading it) from someone who is working with kids and this is his profession( and a guy - I so hope more dads will be involved in this discussion) makes it perfect and valuable input for the readers.

    I hope you will add your thoughts and valuable tips to the next "Top Parenting Bloggers Discuss..." coming up on Friday.

    Thank you
    Ronit

  • HI Jon,

    I am glad you like the captain's analogy.
    I had a parenting workshop yesterday and when I told parents to remember they are the captains of the family ship, I think some of them looked so sad.
    At the end, one of them said " I think in my house, the kids are playing captains. This is why we have a mess"

    I was so happy he said that because it opened a whole discussion about what are the dangers of letting kids run a family ship?
    When kids run the ship, they have a wonderful understanding of "enjoy the present", which is very important in life but their lack of experience and lack of responsibility can lead their ship to very dangerous waters.

    Thanks for your comment
    Happy weekend
    Ronit
    Family Matters

Please share your throughts

Your comment will be moderated by its RELEVANCE and its VALUE to our readers.

Comments links could be nofollow free.

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Ronit Baras

Be Happy in LIFE logo     Find out today
how to be happy in life
with the help of a life coach
Blog by Ronit Baras
Ronit Baras
Suscribe by RSS
RSS icon
Subscribe by Email
How happy are you?
Follow me on
Twitter logo
Be my friend on
Facebook

What would you like to read about most (choose as many as you like)?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...
Help us help you
Spacer image