What is This "Secret" Nonsense?

Some time ago, we visited our good friend Neil, who is married for the second time and lives far away from his son from the first marriage Nathan. Neil had last seen Nathan 11 years before. He had some Photos of Nathan in an album created by his younger son Ben. When Neil had said goodbye his son and moved to another country, Nathan was just 9 years old.

After divorcing his first wife Sue, Neil had a smooth relationship with her. For about 6 years, Neil picked Nathan up from school and spent time with him until Sue finished work and came pick him up for the night. Since Sue worked most weekends, Neil was happy to have Nathan with him almost every weekend. All this changed as soon as Neil met Hannah.

Sue was so unhappy that Nathan's visits at his dad's house became a big problem. When Neil and Hannah got married and had Ben, Sue spent the next two and a half years fighting Neil in court and stopping him from seeing Nathan.

Devastated and unsuccessful at communicating with his ex-wife, Neil left the country in hope that one day, when Nathan is old enough, they would meet again.

On Ben's 12th birthday, Ben asked to go with his dad to see his stepbrother. Ben was just 3 years old the last time he had seen Nathan. He only had vague memories, but the photos of Nathan holding him as a baby were enough for him to ask for this trip as a gift.

A short time later, a letter from Nathan arrived. Neil could not believe his eyes. Attached was a photo of a 20-year-old, gorgeous-looking Nathan in graduation robes and a square hat, having finishing a Psychology degree. Neil so wanted to hug him and the painful memories of the past flooded his mind again.

Nathan said he lived on his own and studied for his Master's degree in another town. Neil called him on the phone and the father and son talked about seeing each other again.

"Come with Ben", asked Nathan, "Let's spend some time together. I have a month off".

Neil was happy for the opportunity but was sad to think it could never happen. He hardly had enough money to support Hannah and their kids. Flight ticket, one month's stay and a month away from work meant they would need $10,000, which was way out of their budget.

clip_image002At first, Hannah said it was important enough for them to take a loan, but their visit in the bank was unsuccessful. Then, Hannah said she would ask her boss for a cash advance, but the money she gave her could hardly cover the airfare.

That week, Neil opened the paper and saw a free talk about "The Secret" (coincidence?). Excited after watching the movie, he went to the talk. The speaker was amazing and the morning after, Neil felt inspired, went to a travel agency and bought a ticket.

Hannah was worried. "But we don't even have enough money for the tickets", she said, "Let's find the money first".

But Neil said, "We have to act as if we have it already. Let's send the right vibes to the universe and the universe will provide", he kept saying.

He emailed me this message less than a month before the flight:

"Ronit, pray for me. The man at the Secret workshop said I had to feel the joy of receiving what I wanted before I actually got it, so I came home and the kids and I jumped for joy and had lots of fun. We screamed happily that we got the money and we were going to see Nathan. It MUST work, because the date is fast approaching and I've only managed to save $400 for the trip. I need another $8,000! I hope this "Secret" stuff works. It must work. It will work! I am going with Ben to see Nathan in 26 days…"

Neil's entire family thought he was crazy. Together with Ben and Nathan, they planned the time of their life together. Whenever someone asked him about the money, he said, "The universe will provide". As the days went by, everyone felt sorry for him. His parents said he'd lost his mind.

Hannah's family thought "this Secret stuff" was nonsense and said he was pathetic. Some of them told Hannah she should not have allowed him to listen to this brainwashing "Secret" person and Hannah was torn between Neil's strong belief in the Secret and reality.

Both Hannah and Neil had worked very hard for the past 5 years. There were no more days in a week to work. Every conversation for 4 weeks was about "The Secret". Like a missionary, Neil tried to convince his family and friends that all he needed to do was to truly want the trip and he would get it. Being an atheist, everyone thought he had lost it and tried to convince him to cancel the tickets so he does not lose the money, but he kept saying, "The money will come".

A week before their departure, we visited Neil and Hannah. During lunch, Neil excitedly told us that the night before, his brother-in-law had called and said:

"Neil, I think you are totally nuts with this "Secret" stuff. You just can't believe in things like that. Money doesn't just pop up. The universe doesn't provide and asking for what you want isn't enough. I'm worried about you. You have to promise me to stop this nonsense with this "Secret". I'll give you $10,000 as a loan, which you can give me back when you can. No rush. But promise me you won't go on believing in this "Secret" nonsense…"

On Wednesday, the 23rd of July, Ben got his birthday wish and Neil got to fly half way around the world to see his son after missing him terribly for 11 years.

What do you think? Did The Law of Attraction work, or is it just nonsense?

Buy The Secret (Book) or The Secret (Extended Edition DVD) on Amazon

You may want to read

  • http://www.parental-intelligence.com Bob Collier

    I think Neil was fortunate he had a brother-in-law who was willing to bail him out.

  • http://www.behappyinlife.com/ Ronit Baras

    Neil,

    Fortunate?
    I don't know.
    He had the same brother in law for many years but still couldn't see his son.

    I would like to believe that we can attract luck.

    Happy weekend
    Ronit
    http://www.behappyinlife.com

  • http://www.parental-intelligence.com Bob Collier

    I agree that we make our own luck. :-)

    I know from my own experiences over many years that there's a correlation between what we think about and what happens to us in our lives. I just don't believe that it works in the manner of a magnetic "attraction". Or that there has to necessarily always be a metaphysical explanation. I think in this particular case the result was purely psychological.

    I recall that after Rhonda Byrne's movie The Secret was released (March 2006?), one of the producers created an online forum for people to discuss the movie and the 'Law of Attraction' (it was called Powerful Intentions, probably it's still there). The forum's logo wasn't a magnet, as I would have expected, it was a tuning fork.

    I think, as an explanation for what might be happening in the metaphysical world, a 'Law of Resonance' makes more sense. To me, that is.

  • http://subliminalmentalperception.com/blog Mental Perception

    Great message in this post! As always, you're more than welcome to check out what I have on my site at: http://subliminalmentalperception.com/blog take care!

    Mental Perception

  • http://www.quantumcreators.com Mike

    Hello

    Single parents don't have time to sit and meditate. Much of The Secret and what spiritual guru's tell us about visualization involve elaborate time consuming rituals. I have created a quick simple alternative that people can do driving to work or while getting ready for work. Something that might crack the door to enlightenment enough that they can catch a breath and change their lives.

    I am a composer and I have written a number of music tracks based around positive visualization. I wrote them for myself to change my own life and get myself and my family out of the negative hole we were stuck in.

    My visualizations are VERY different from the regular wind chimes and flutes they contain rock guitar and dance tracks and they are all short 3 – 6 mins and to the point.

    I don't know about you but I don’t have time to meditate for an hour a day but I can play 3 tracks every morning while I get ready for work. Many of my tracks are great to exercise to with up tempo beats.

    Transformation and creation come from quality visualization which in turn comes from repetition. Just like physical exercise reps build muscle in this case reps bring change.

    Let’s move the world to the creative paradigm.

    You can hear samples on http://www.quantumcreators.com and purchase tracks for 99 cents

    Mike

    Put QC’s on your site and earn 15% as an affiliate.

  • http://www.behappyinlife.com/ Ronit Baras

    Mike,

    You are right. I know so many people that say they do not have time to mediate. The turth is that if they do not think they have time, they won't have time.

    I went to your website and listened to some of the music and loved it. It was great, I really loved the music.

    I'll buy some and try them in the car, while taking the kids to school. I have more than 6 minutes for that.

    Thanks for writing.
    I mediated myself ( the long 20 min twich a day) and it works but I agree that we need something shorter.

    Happy day
    Ronit
    http://www.behappyinlife.com

  • http://www.behappyinlife.com/ Ronit Baras

    Hi Bob,

    I agree that it is not really magic and our psychological state had a huge effect on our reality.
    I think "The law of attraction" is not really a magnet, I believe it is a metaphor. I am a great believer of the power of the self-fulfilling prophecy. I think this is the real meaning of attraction.
    Here is what I believe in:
    http://www.ronitbaras.com/index.php/2008/07/focus-on-the-family/kids-children/magic-in-little-hands/

    I like the idea of the tuning fork though I am not sure everyone can relate to it as easy as the magnet. Still both are metaphors. All laws are just explanations for people to find strength and power. If "Law of resonance" makes more sense to you, that is cool. We only adopt the ideas that relate that what we think, feel and believe anyway.
    By the way Bob, I went to your website, I love what you are doing. We share so many ideas. It is wonderful.

    Happy day
    Ronit
    http://www.behappyinlife.com

Ronit Baras

Be Happy in LIFE logo    Book your private life coaching
with Ronit Baras and learn
how to be happy in life
Keep up to date

RSS icon

Facebook

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner